Cavan M. McCarthy, Ph.D., Visiting Professor
School of Library and Information Science
The University of Iowa

ELECTRONIC INFORMATION AND ACADEMIC LIBRARIES
COLLEGE AND UNIVERSITY LIBRARIES
FALL 2000

TEACHING NOTES FOR:
Budd, John M. The academic library: its context, its purpose, and its operation. Libraries Unlimited, 1998.  (Library and Information Science Text Series). Ch. 10: Electronic information and academic libraries; pp. 246 - 273.
 

NON-PRINT:

MICROFORM
Major legacy collections in academic libraries
Barriers to local transfer to digital media:
copyright, expense, specialized equipment
Transfer by microform publisher: library buys material again?
Microform collections likely to remain
maintain equipment, collections
Purchase major microfilm collections now?
Unlikely: digital media can easily be indexed
Microfilm as backup for digital library collections:
possible until digital tablet developed

IDC (Microfilm etc.)
http://www.idc.nl/

Does anybody have experience with these materials?
AUDIOVISUAL
Certain areas will continue to use audiovisual materials:
Music, Fine Arts, Dance, Medicine:
separate formats, equipment
(until / unless all formats, equipment converge)

Does anybody have experience with these materials?
 

ELECTRONIC:

LIBRARY AUTOMATION
simply automated existing card catalogs
additional access points / Boolean access
to same information bibliographic descriptions
no improved subject access / post-coordinated terms
no contents lists, reviews, comments:
rare in libraries (common with Internet booksellers!)
distant holds / patron data only generally available:
webcats: 1997-
currently rare, timid moves towards:
widespread Z39.50 searching
Future:
library catalog as entry point to universal information
(or vice versa?)
linking to Internet resources
modification of MARC format:
MARC tags substituted by metadata?

Does anybody have experience with these materials?
 

ONLINE SEARCHING
First major electronic / outside service in academic libraries
formerly: complex search interfaces
intermediated searches
use limited by interview system
library often paid host for each search
Currently: simplified search interfaces
user searches directly
via controlled gateway
Dialog, Proquest: unlimited use
to campus against negotiated fee
or via agents: OCLC, EBSCO, FAXON etc.

Access from University of Iowa campus network connections:
http://sirius.lib.uiowa.edu/cgi-bin/ovidweb.cgi

Does anybody have experience with these services?
 

CD-ROM
First introduced in (academic) medical libraries
Reference materials transferred to CD-ROM
Reference books: a dying breed?
CD-ROM: salable physical object, like book
Originally: exchange ID card for disc
Stand-alone systems
One disc one machine one printer (Medline)
Now: licensing for campus-wide use
CD tower
limited number of simultaneous users
Occasional products: single-user licenses
CD-ROM: Short life or continued by DVD?

Does anybody have experience with these materials?
 

INTERNET ACCESS
Ample free access now normal in academic libraries
Filtering inappropriate; few problems:
relatively controlled environment

LIBRARY NETWORK
Same terminal / micro should offer access to:
Internet
Webcat / Library gateway /
Online databases / E-Journals /
CD-ROMs
Secure / impossible to alter LAN
Virus-proof: no floppies
 

LIBRARY WEB GATEWAY
Essential entry point
http://www.library.arizona.edu/

http://www.lib.berkeley.edu

Well-designed / organized / links to:
WEB CATALOGS

http://dpweb1.dp.utexas.edu/lib/utnetcat/
enter terms in separate boxes, select operator;
limit to location / format / language /
place of publication / year of publication
(note pop-up boxes for frequently-used choices).
Catalog will even identify books with special bindings:
try poetry and vellum (i.e. system indexes words in notes).
Links direct to some digitized maps:
(e.g. try Kuwait and maps
select subject keywords if searching from quick search box;
from picklist click on a long URL ending in .jpg, .gif etc.)

http://www.melvyl.ucop.edu
Union Catalog U. California; Melvyl catalog:
"California Digital Library"
select long display for details;
includes some periodical articles:
select format analytics
sophisticated e-mail:
user can add note, include / exclude diacritics.

http://library.unm.edu/
University of New Mexico Web catalog;
offers MARC format, will export via e-mail or to local disk;
will even download in MARC communication format
direct to local hard disk;
Innovative Interfaces software
 

ACCESS TO NETWORK HOLDINGS

http://www.aladin.wrlc.org
Washington (DC) Research Library Consortium:
Aladin: Access to Library and Database Information Network;
will show MARC format;
Marc format / save: will show communications format
OCLC system

http://copac.ac.uk/copac/
COPAC:
(CURL (Consortium of University Research Libraries) OPAC):
Unified web access to major British university libraries

http://cicvel.lib.uiowa.edu/
 

RECOMMENDED  SITES

http://www.albany.edu/library/virtual/subject/
 

CONTROLLED ACCESS AREAS
online systems / CD-ROMs / E-journals etc.
 

HOLDS ETC.
Permits holds,
gives patrons information on their loans, holds
http://dpweb1.dp.utexas.edu/lib/utnetcat/help_due.html
Scroll down one page to:
Due-List/Renew Lists and Services
 
 

Tutorials / floorplans / photographs of building
http://library.ucsc.edu/library/ref/instruction/skit/

Staff / bibliographers / e-mail address for contact
Library mission / collection development policies
Opening hours / regulations
Link to mother university / college
Link to other local sites: city, state etc.
 

E-JOURNALS
Originally: full-text journals on CD-ROM (ABI-Inform)
(direct or via Proquest)
Cataloging: major task
Range of journals could change
(microfilm: similar mass cataloging problem,
but permanent acquisition)
Now: e-journals: various possibilities:
electronic only (free / paid)
select paper or electronic
electronic version only available to subscribers of paper
Free e-journals: treated like other Internet resources
listed on gateway, not in catalog
Publishers undecided:
whether to permit subscription to electronic only
how to charge (paper / electronic: often 110% of paper)
E-journals: indicate permanence of journals
or constitute a transitory stage
between journals and electronic communication?
E-journals: so far no relief from journal price spiral
Guaranteeing access to e-journals:
controlled gateway on library site /
by IP address (on-campus desktops only)
Same gateway: e-journals, online system (EBSCO, OCLC)
Cataloging e-journals: complex; two versions;
link from catalog to e-journal address (permanent?)
http://www.lib.umich.edu/libhome/ejournals/
Include free e-journals?
Check-in of e-journals: trust agent!?!?
Back collections: electronic versions may disappear:
future role of library: guaranteeing continuing access to e-journal backruns!
(guarantee digital access to non-commercial materials in general?!?)

SPARC: Scholarly Publishing and Academic Resources Coalition
http://www.arl.org/sparc/factsheet.html
Cooperative alternatives to high-priced publications,
especially in Science, Technology and Medicine
low start-up costs:
possible to transfer journal publishing to
professional associations / universities etc.?

Create Change: A resource for faculty and librarian
action to reclaim scholarly communication:
http://www.arl.org/create/home.html

International Consortium for the Advancement of
Academic Publication, Athabasca University, Canada
http://www.icaap.org/

http://www.lib.iastate.edu/library/scholcomm/homepage.html
 

Elsevier:
http://www.sciencedirect.com/

SYNERGY:
Combined list of Scientific, Medical and Technical journals:
Links lead to contents list; full text in .pdf files
Non-subscribers can purchase single items
http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/
List:
http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/journallist.asp

New Journal of Physics
http://www.njp.org/

http://southernlibrarianship.icaap.org/

http://www.jstor.org/

http://muse.jhu.edu/
 

DIGITAL LIBRARIES
Hybrid library: foreseeable future
Academic library as focal point for university digitization program
Creation of digital library:
Identify items, editions, obtain originals
Obtain permission to digitize
Determine method (HTML, .pdf etc.)
Digitize and verify (scanning errors in HTML)
Index: determine procedures, stopwords
Organize digital library site (mission, citations)
Maintain on server 24/7
Maintain permanent backup / copy of original text

The University of Virginia Electronic Text Center:
1992- ; HTML-style texts:
http://etext.lib.virginia.edu

Berkeley Digital Library SunSITE:
http://sunsite.berkeley.edu/
California heritage:
http://sunsite.berkeley.edu/CalHeritage/
Digital Scriptorium: images of Renaissance literature:
http://sunsite.berkeley.edu/Scriptorium
Search Plimpton MS 281
fourth image: elephant

Classical studies:
http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/

Library of Virginia:
http://www.lva.lib.va.us/dlp/index.htm
World's Fair Photo collection

University of Michigan: Digital Library Initiatives:
http://henry.ugl.lib.umich.edu/libhome/DLI/
Monographs / Smith / Family religion

(Lucretia Maria Davis / Poetical remains
(on t.p. as Davidson)

Traveling culture: circuit Chatauqua:
American memory project of the University of Iowa Libraries:
http://sdrc.lib.uiowa.edu/traveling-culture/

Mary Noble Postcard Collection: Iowa Women's Archives
http://mingo.info-science.uiowa.edu/Mary_Noble/htm_folder/the_mary_noble_postcard_co.htm
 

COMMERCIAL DIGITAL LIBRARIES

netLibrary:
Pioneer; collections of digitized books
for use by members of specific communities
Academic, corporate, public, school libraries
One person at a time can read book(!!)
One page at a time: rapid page turning:
considered printing out, not allowed
http://www.netlibrary.com/

See Libraries / types of library
scroll down to sample e-book

Via consortia: BCR:
http://www.bcr.org/~shoffhin/2000/junnetlib.html

New start-ups:

http://www.nytimes.com/library/tech/00/06/circuits/articles/15book.html

http://www.questia.com/

http://www.ebrary.com/
 

ELECTRONIC THESES AND DISSERTATIONS

Initial steps taken
May grow rapidly in future
XML formats being investigated
Many thesis authors aim at eventual book publication

West Virginia University
http://www.wvu.edu/~thesis/

NDLTD: Networked Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations
http://www.ndltd.org/
http://www.theses.org/

http://thesis.mit.edu/

http://theses.mit.edu/Dienst/UI/2.0/Describe/0018.mit.etheses%2f2000-4
 

COPYRIGHT

University of Texas: Copyright Crash Course:
http://www.utsystem.edu/OGC/IntellectualProperty/cprtindx.htm
http://www.utsystem.edu/ogc/intellectualproperty/l-intro.htm

Copyright Clearance Center
1978- ; Licensing systems for reproduction and distribution
of copyrighted materials in print and electronic formats
manages rights relating to over 1.75 million works
from more than 9,600 publishers
U.S. customers: over 9,000 corporations
(including 90 of the Fortune 100 companies)
government agencies, law firms, document suppliers,
libraries, academic institutions, copy shops, bookstores
Located Danvers, Massachusetts
http://www.copyright.com/
 

DMCA:
Digital Millennium Copyright Act, 1998
Non-profit library or archive can make up to three copies
(e.g.  archival, master, use copy)
for preservation, ILL, substitution of worn copies
if unable to purchase copy at fair price
Copies can be digital:
Digital copies cannot be made available to public
outside library premises
Can copy from one format to another
if original device no longer available

Amendments to Section 108, 1976 Law:
DMCA US Copyright Office Summary p. 15; .pdf file:
http://lcweb.loc.gov/copyright/legislation/dmca.pdf

Nobody can distribute digital copies from which
electronic rights management information
(name of copyright holder, date, etc.)
has been removed (or modified) without authority
Remedy: civil action for damages;
non-profit libraries, archives and educational institutions
are not liable for damages if they were not aware
and had no reason to believe
their acts constituted a violation

Nonprofit libraries, archives:
can circumvent protective software
in order to evaluate digital materials
to determine whether they wish to obtain
authorized access

UCITA:
Uniform Computer Information Transactions Act
http://www.arl.org/ucita.html
 

ELECTRONIC RESERVE ROOMS

Similar to other fair-use restrictions;
small part of work;
use password for outside access;
multi-semester use: ask for license
omit author / title index to electronic reserves;
access by instructor's name, course number only

http://www.utsystem.edu/ogc/intellectualproperty/copypol2.htm#reserve

Electronic Reserves Clearing House:
http://www.cc.columbia.edu/~rosedale/#SPEC

SPEC Flyer 245
Electronic Reserves Operations in ARL Libraries
http://www.arl.org/spec/245fly.html

Electronic Course Reserves at San Diego State University:
http://ecr.sdsu.edu
Copyright statement from SDSU:
http://libweb.sdsu.edu/copyright.html
 

LICENSING

Sign only:
When certain that you have authority to sign
After full review / consultation
After understanding all the terms
When certain that no better terms can be obtained

Relevant considerations:

NETWORKING AND REMOTE ACCESS
Library wants to make information available
on campus / company-wide network
Supplier may wish to limit number of concurrent users
Library will want remote access for authorized users
Supplier may be cautious over this

AUTHORIZED USERS
Library: Members of institution in wide sense:
University: include part-time students, distance education,
community members / walk-ins;
avoid complex authorizations that create barriers to access:
IP address / proxy server / frequently changed passwords
Supplier: may wish to limit to formal members
insist on secure access

OWNERSHIP OF DATA / ARCHIVING
Library: accustomed to permanent ownership of material acquired
Expects permanent access for digital materials, e.g. e-journals
If library cancels subscription
does library still have access to those years / issues?
(Project Muse guarantees this)
Is there a print copy / alternative source?
(e.g. from dual paper / electronic subscription)
Can library make its own archival copy?
Can authorized users download reasonable amounts to disc?
Supplier: may offer the library a backfile in e.g. tape form
may even take materials down unexpectedly

PRICE STABILITY
Supplier may initially offer product at low price /
offer large number of concurrent users
then increase price sharply / limit users
when library is dependent on product

INTERLIBRARY LENDING
Traditional / considered essential in libraries
Treated by caution by suppliers
Considered possible loss of market
Can library send printouts to fulfill ILL requests?
Can library send digital copies to fulfill ILL requests
Is there a print copy that can be used to fill ILL requests?

WARRANTIES
Supplier guarantees quality, modifications, updates
Rapid, competent help-desk services

CONSORTIAL LICENSING
Library consortia now firmly established
Consortial licenses difficult to negotiate
Suppliers may treat with caution
prefer separate licenses

LIBLICENSE: Licensing Digital Information:
A Resource for Librarians:
http://www.library.yale.edu/~llicense/index.shtml

ARL (Association of Research Libraries)
Links to sites dealing with licensing:
http://www.arl.org/scomm/licensing/index.html
Note especially: Principles for licensing electronic resources:
AALL / ALA / ARL / MLA / SLA etc.:
http://www.arl.org/scomm/licensing/principles.html
Licensing electronic resources:
http://arl.cni.org/scomm/licensing/licbooklet.html
 

FINANCIAL ASPECTS
All applications of electronic (and non-print)
media in library have been additional to historic role:
depository style services
offering books and periodicals: then came:

microfilm, a/v,
automation, online services, CD-ROMs,
Internet access, e-journals, digital library services:

all additional expense, specialized materials, equipment:
so far no additional source of income

Future model:
Library as licensing center:
selecting / negotiating / paying
online / e-journal
digital coursepack suppliers
setting up digital libraries
for campus-wide access

likely perspective for the future:
very different from what has  come before
Will come first to special and university libraries

Some possible return:
disseminating campus information to world
Sufficient to cover additional financial requirements?
 

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES

WHEN LIBRARIES FACED THE FUTURE:
ONLINE INFORMATION ISN'T JUST A NEW MEDIUM
BUT A WHOLE NEW WAY OF DOING BUSINESS.
HERE'S HOW RESEARCH LIBRARIES MASTERED IT.
http://www.universitybusiness.com/0002/library.html

Negotiating the Deal: How Libraries Craft Their
Contracts With Publishers
http://www.universitybusiness.com/0002/libcraft.html
 
 

Updated:  2000 Sep. 25          Conditions of use
Return to opening page of Prof. McCarthy's site
Click here to send e-mail to Prof. McCarthy